Grandma Bettie Jane's Pies taste just like grandmas!

Grandma Bettie Jane’s Pies are made from scratch and baked fresh daily in our store.
A variety of pies are available daily. Orders can be placed in our bakery for your favorite fruit or cream pies.
Orders for cream pies require a 24-hour notice.

Grandma Bettie Jane’s Pies are also available in the freezer section to take and bake!

Available exclusively at Schaefer’s Foods!

To order your favorite
Grandma Bettie Jane's pie,
call our bakery at 218-963-2265.

Grandma Bettie Jane's Pie Flavors:

Fruit Pies:

Apple

Apple Caramel

Apple Dutch

Blackberry/Peach (Summer Only)

Blueberry

Blueberry Cream

Bumbleberry

Cherry

Cherry Raspberry

Fruit of the Orchards

Peach (Summer Only)

Pecan

Pumpkin (Fall Only)

Raspberry (Summer Only)

Rhubarb

Rhubarb Custard

Strawberry Rhubarb

Wildberry

Cream Pies:

Fruit Pies:

Banana Cream

Chocolate Cream

Coconut Cream

French Silk

Hershey Bar

Key Lime Chiffon

Key Lime Meringue

Lemon Meringue

Peanut Butter Fudge

Sour Cream Raisin

Fresh Strawberry*

Egg Nog Cream (Christmas Season Only)

Pina Colada (Summer Only)